
Six ex-executives, including the publication’s former publisher and editors, argued that their cooperation with authorities and relatively limited involvement in the offences warranted reduced penalties before the court determines final sentences at a later date.
The defendants admitted guilt in 2022 to conspiracy to collude with foreign forces under Hong Kong’s national security law, acknowledging that they conspired with their former boss, media tycoon Jimmy Lai, to seek foreign sanctions, blockades or other actions perceived as hostile to Hong Kong and China.
Guilty pleas under the security law can qualify for reduced sentences, and lawyers appearing for the former executives highlighted factors such as timely admissions, cooperation with prosecutors and lesser roles in the alleged conduct as grounds for mitigation.
Among those seeking leniency was associate publisher Chan Pui-man, whose counsel suggested that, even if the court applied an upper sentencing band, her sentence should start at around ten years and be halved in recognition of her mitigation factors.
Defence submissions also cited personal circumstances, including health issues and financial burdens, to contextualise decisions made while working at Apple Daily.
Apple Daily, established in 1995 and closed in 2021 following police raids and asset freezes, was a leading pro-democracy voice in Hong Kong.
Its shuttering dealt a significant blow to the city’s once vibrant press landscape, and the ongoing case, with Lai awaiting sentencing on related convictions, has drawn international attention and commentary on the state of media and civil liberties under the national security law.
The judge has yet to set a date for sentencing, with proceedings paused after mitigation arguments concluded.
Observers note that how the court balances calls for leniency against the statutory penalties—ranging up to life imprisonment for national security offences—could influence perceptions of judicial independence and the future of dissent in Hong Kong.










































